Friday, October 07, 2005

Immortality and the Potential Obsolescence of the Self


I recently co-founded a group called the DC Future Salon that meets once a month in Bethesda, Maryland, to discuss futurist issues (if you live near DC and want to join, join the dcfuture group on yahoogroups). This week our salon meeting focused on the notion of immortality. After a nice lecture and movie showing by Immortality Institute founder (and DC Future Salon co-organizer) Bruce Klein, the discussion traveled through various topics, including the viability of cryonics and the politics of discussing immortality among nontranshumanists – and finally, moved on to more philosophical issues, such as the reasons why immortality is desirable. One of the key issues that came up here is the extent to which the individual self, the personal identity – the thing most transhumanists want most to preserve via immortality, much more so than our physical bodies – is actually a real thing worth preserving. Preserving the physical body is, like uploading, just one means to preserving the self. But what is this “self” that’s so valuable to persist throughout time?

There is a lot of neuropsychological research showing that the “self” is in a strong sense an illusion – much like its sister illusion, “free will.” Thomas Metzinger’s recent book Being No One makes this point in an excellently detailed way. The human mind’s image of itself – what Metzinger calls the “phenomenal self” – is in fact a construct that the human mind creates in order to better understand and control itself, it’s not a “real thing.” Various neuropsychological disorders may lead to bizarre dysfunctions in self-image and self-understanding. And there are valid reasons to speculate that a superhuman mind – be it an AI or a human with tremendously augmented intelligence – might not possess this same illusion. Rather than needing to construct for itself a story of a unified “self entity” controlling it, a more intelligent and introspective mind might simply perceive itself as the largely heterogenous collection of patterns and subsystems that it is. In this sense, individuality might not survive the transcendence of minds beyond the human condition.

The key philosophical point here is: What is the goal of immortality? Or, to put it more precisely: What is the goal of avoiding involuntary death? Is it to keep human life as we know it around forever? That is a valid and non-idiotic goal. Or is it to keep the process of growth alive and flourishing beyond the scope painfully and arbitrarily imposed on it by the end of the human life?

Human life as it exists now is not a constant, it's an ongoing growth process; and for those who want it to be, human life beyond the current maximum lifespan and beyond the traditional scope of humanity will still be a process of growth, change and learning. Fear of death will largely be replaced by more interesting issues like the merit of individuality in its various forms -- and other issues we can't come close to foreseeing yet.

It may be that, when we live long enough and become smart enough, what we find out is that maintaining individuality unto eternity isn't interesting, and it's better to merge into a larger posthuman intelligent dynamical-pattern-system. Or it may be that what we find out is that individuality still seems interesting forever, since there are so many resources available at the posthuman stage, and diversity still seems like an interesting value (plenty of room for both humans and transhuman intelligent dynamical pattern systems!).

The quest for radical life extension is largely about staying around to find out about things like this!

And there is, of course, a familiar and acute irony in observing that -- while these (along with the scientific puzzles of human biology, uploading and so forth) are the interesting issues regarding immortality -- the public discourse on immortality will be focusing on much less fascinating aspects for quite some time to come: aspects like whether living forever is a violation of the will of the divine superbeing who created us all 6000 years ago....


19 comments:

Anonymous said...

Personally, I know I like the feeling of happiness, whether it comes from drugs or new love or the feeling of accomplishment in coming nearer toward a solution to some scientific problem. Let's make sure that sticks around (and augment it too if we can)...
Alcibiades

Andrew Lewis said...

Your thoughts about immortality institute are enough to understand your visions and you have raised the point of "self" which is more important about your physic, every person meet to your self which is fair enough to introduce other person. I have completed an assignment by getting help from anthropology assignment help online service and covered same topic over there.

Aadil said...

Thanks for sharing such great information with us. If you guys are looking for high quality Electrical Conduit Pipe Fittings so, you can choose Adamjee DuraBuilt hope this will be best choice for you.

Kalvin said...

very informative Thanks for sharing. keep sharing, keep updating.

also get the best generator maintenance service according to your need from Synergy Corporation.

Eon Morgan said...

Personally, I know I enjoy the feeling of happiness, whether it comes from drugs, new love, or the sense of accomplishment that comes from getting closer to a solution to a scientific problem. I offer wordpress development services as well as site design bolt. extremely instructive Thank you for your contribution. Continue to share and update.

james said...

Great post!I have been reading this blog for the last night.It was really helpful and informative for me and all the readers.If you are looking to buy an online Sentiments Express service to help the students at an affordable and reasonable price.

elisjohn said...

The people reading this article and loving the delivery style of the content writer, Must know that the job of a content writer is really hectic. They have to deliver their content on time which makes it very hectic for them. The content writers working for the watch channel 4 in the us platform also spend working for hours but use the platform delivering the services of movies and web series which enables them to produce much better and productive results.

DTFLIX said...

Episode1: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=44lIIa3Agv8&list=PLDPEtzCBbGIRq7JSXUcq3aL9TCzjbR6bH&index=3
Episode2: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VB--pV59akA&list=PLDPEtzCBbGIRq7JSXUcq3aL9TCzjbR6bH&index=6
Episode3: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RJHkUozsiXA&list=PLDPEtzCBbGIRq7JSXUcq3aL9TCzjbR6bH&index=8
Episode4: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cjWVPrQQBoE&list=PLDPEtzCBbGIRq7JSXUcq3aL9TCzjbR6bH&index=10
Episode5: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NYAxBH5VZSo&list=PLDPEtzCBbGIRq7JSXUcq3aL9TCzjbR6bH&index=12
Episode6: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OdFiwCbD2Us&list=PLDPEtzCBbGIRq7JSXUcq3aL9TCzjbR6bH&index=14
Episode7: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n3n-ht36sBU&list=PLDPEtzCBbGIRq7JSXUcq3aL9TCzjbR6bH&index=16

blockchain developer companies said...


Immortality definitely has the potential to change our view of the self and our mortality. If we were to live forever, it would certainly challenge our concept of identity and how we define ourselves. We would have to rethink how we measure value and accomplishment since our ultimate goal would no longer be to make the most of our finite lives. This could lead to a situation where our sense of self has become obsolete, as we would no longer be driven by the same standards of success. It will be interesting to see how this potential shift in perspective affects our society and how we view ourselves in the future.

Anonymous said...

Do you want to watch Footballers’ Wives in USA

buy cpu online said...

This is a fascinating topic filled with many ethical implications. The idea that immortality could potentially lead to a weakening of the self is concerning, as it challenges our core understanding of identity. It is important to consider the ways in which technology and immortality could alter our conception of the self and how this might impact our sense of purpose and morality. There is also an ethical responsibility to consider how this kind of technology might be used and whether its use could be considered a breach of ethical boundaries.

Will Steven said...

Seeking a How Much Does a Uncontested Divorce Cost in Virginia? Our skilled lawyer can provide a legal advice

manjusha20 said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Alexander_01 said...

"Contemplate the profound concept of immortality and its implications on selfhood. Explore the intricate interplay between technology and the essence of the self. Delve into our thought-provoking discussions as we navigate the fascinating realms of potential self-obsolescence and the profound consequences of achieving immortality." This blog is a goldmine of information. Your blog packs a punch in just a few sentences. Your words are like gems. Thank you for sharing this! A quick, delightful read that left me inspired.how to get a divorce in va

Henry John said...


Dive into the captivating exploration of selfhood and immortality on this blog, where the profound implications of these concepts are dissected with intellectual finesse. The intricate interplay between technology and the essence of self is a subject masterfully covered. As I read through your thought-provoking discussions, it became evident that your blog is a goldmine of information. Your succinct yet impactful writing style, akin to precious gems, makes for a quick and delightful read. Thank you for sharing this inspiring content! If you're intrigued by technological marvels, check out the SG350X-48P-K9-NA for a glimpse into the future of networking.

visaconsultant said...

In the dynamic landscape of Pakistan's construction industry, where quality, innovation, and sustainability are paramount, IGL German emerges as a beacon of excellence. With a rich legacy of delivering cutting-edge construction solutions, IGL German has redefined the standards of excellence in the country's built environment. This blog delves into the story of IGL German, highlighting its journey, ethos, and contributions to sustainable construction practices in Pakistan

IGL (Institue of German Language) said...

A comfortable and ergonomically designed chair is essential for maintaining productivity and well-being in any office environment. As the demand for quality office furniture grows in Pakistan, GlobalOffice chairs emerge as a preferred choice for businesses and professionals seeking both comfort and style. In this blog, we'll delve into the world of GlobalOffice chairs, exploring their features, benefits, and prices in Pakistan, to help you create a workspace that inspires productivity and promotes good posture office chair

Anonymous said...

Craftsmanship and Quality:
GlobalOffice chairs are renowned for their superior craftsmanship and attention to detail. Constructed using high-quality materials such as durable upholstery, sturdy frames, and ergonomic padding, these chairs are built to withstand the rigors of daily use while providing optimal comfort and support. office furniture Whether you're spending long hours at your desk or attending meetings, GlobalOffice chairs offer a luxurious seating experience that enhances your overall well-being and productivity. office furniture in karachi

Anonymous said...

women sunglasses:

Sunglasses are a popular accessory worn to protect the eyes from harmful UV rays and bright sunlight, as well as to make a fashion statement. women sunglasses come in a wide variety of styles, shapes, and colors to suit different preferences and face shapes. Sunglasses Price in Pakistan