Monday, September 14, 2020

Sand Talk, Singularity and Psi


It’s not that often I encounter a newly authored book that I consider a “must read” and avidly recommend to all my friends and colleagues -- but Sand Talk by Tyson Yunkaporta genuinely falls into this category.   


I was introduced to the book by Jim Rutt who interviewed the author on his podcast -- an episode I also strongly recommend.


Yunkaporta is an Australian Aboriginal whose core goal in the book is to present and analyze modern civilization society from the perspective of Aboriginal indigenous society.   He does a bang-up job of this and raises a lot of related interesting issues along the way.


I’m not going to give a proper review or summary of the book here, but am mostly going to share various indirectly-related thoughts that occurred to me upon reading the book.   If you want a basic overview of the themes of the book try this brief interview with the author.


Was Civilization a Step Forward, or Backward?


It is hard to really give an "outsider" view of something as big as *human civilization* , but Yunkaporta manages to take a decent stab at it....  He is able to pull this off by virtue of being fascinatingly between the two worlds -- ensconced enough in Aboriginal culture to understand their indigenous world-view on the multiple relevant levels; but also embedded enough in the modern intellectual world to explain aspects of the indigenous world view (in the context of contrast with modernity & civilization) in ways that are clear and straightforward and compelling  to those of us accustomed to modern verbal/analytical modes of expression ...


There are hilarious things in the book -- e.g. the analogy and possible historical relationship btw modern education systems and methodologies for animal domestication.   


There are beautifully conceptually insightful things, like the discussion of multiple forms of human understanding -- pattern mind, kinship mind, dreaming mind, story-mind, ancestor-mind -- and the observation of how biased modern civilized culture is toward some of these and away from others.  


There are disturbingly thought-provoking things, like his discussion of public vs. private violence and the relation between physical and psychological violence (he believes that occasional/ moderate physical violence in indigenous societies plays a valuable social-psychological role, which it can't play in modern society due to the different sort of organization).  


All in all he makes a reasonably compelling case that the states of consciousness of indigenous people -- and the "collective minds" of indigenous tribal groups (to use my own fancy language that he probably would not approve of, he is very very down to earth in the book) -- were much more satisfied and fundamentally healthy than the vast majority of individual and human-collective-group minds on the planet today...


He views civilization as mostly destructive both to human minds and families and bodies, and to the rest of the physical environment on the planet…


I largely agree with the core points Yunkaporta makes in the book, but of course I have a somewhat different slant on the conclusions/ideas.  (The rest of this post is now my own musing and  rambling, some of which Yunkaporta might well utterly disagree with...)  


What Drives Humanity?


The transition from hunter-gatherer to agricultural society and then to modern civilization probably has degraded happiness and mental and social health in many important

senses, as Yunkaporta points out.   


So it is certainly meaningful to question whether these transitions have really been “advances” as is commonly assumed.


However, it’s also important to understand that the driver of these transitions has never really been to increase happiness or mental/social health!   Put crudely, “happiness” (a concept very tricky to define) is not necessarily what humans have been after...


Humans and human groups are complex with multiple motivations -- and the drive for fundamental novelty and growth is one of them.


Aboriginal society was stable for 60,000 years, and certainly allowed individuals to pursue their drive for novelty and growth  through stories and dreaming and battles and adventures -- but it did not allow human-groups much avenue to pursue the drive for novelty and growth.   


It would seem that, once human-groups got a taste of fulfillment of their novelty-and-growth goal, they became addicted to it and things just snowballed till we got where we are today…


Singularity as Paradise Regained and Transcended


So what do to now?  Yunkaporta does not really suggest rolling back to indigenous society, because he's a realist and can see this is not too likely to happen except in the aftermath of some disaster scenario (which seems strangely possible to me at the moment, as I write these words sitting here on an island near Seattle with the air so full of smoke one can barely see a few hundred meters out into the ocean… smoke due to forest fires that are spreading like mad through the US West due to heat and dryness that is likely substantially due to industry-induced climate warming....  But yeah yeah... the smoke is supposed to clear over the next couple days...)


Personally, as you probably know, I think we are on the verge of another shift even bigger than the shift from hunter-gatherer to civilization (Singularity, anyone?) ... and as we attempt to guide ourselves through this shift, it seems very important to keep in mind the various aspects of human individual and group life that have been squelched in the transition to civilization -- Perhaps these aspects can be regained in a different form as we move into the next phase....


Yunkaporta refers to modern civilized thinking as "context-free" thinking , whereas indigenous thinking is contextually-embedded -- i.e. in the context of a network of social relationships, a specific area of land, etc.   This is a deep point that I am still in the process of fully absorbing.   There is an indirect connection here to the relational interpretation of quantum mechanics, in which there are no pure phenomena, only (observer, phenomenon) pairs.   But much of our thinking these days is done as if there are pure phenomena.


On the other hand, fundamentally, embedding thinking in contexts defined by kinship and physical place is only one possible way of embedding thinking -- there are many other sorts of possible contexts.   It's arguable that these particular sorts of contexts are intrinsically central to humanity, due to the way our bodies and brains are built.   On the other hand the Singularity is partly about going beyond the restrictions of legacy humanity.   


It seems clear that we want to be sure post-Singularity minds including early-stage AGIs and cyborgs are able to engage in richly context-sensitive thinking, regarding contexts defined by kinship networks and other social networks and specific physical locations -- but also other contexts beyond these historically critical examples.


From an indigenous view -- or a conventional modern civilized human view -- one could view this sort of idea as overweening and narcissistic .. i.e. how can we, who are born to human moms and live our lives walking around in the dirt and stuffing ourselves with food grown in the earth and nourished with water and sunlight -- sensibly talk about going beyond kinship and physical location into some sort of airy  domain of  abstract contexts?   But we have built computer chips and brain scanners and open-heart surgery and brain surgery and virtual reality and birth control and IVF and gone to the moon and blow up atom bombs and on and on -- while we have indeed lost a lot of important stuff relative to our indigenous forebears, there is also obviously a huge amount of power in the crazy path we civilized folks have blazed...


Inspiration Regarding Psi from the Indigenous Perspective


Another aspect of Yunkaporta’s book that jumped out at me -- though it was fairly peripheral in his narrative -- was the Aboriginal approach to psi (psychic, paranormal phenomena…).   (For some references on the science of psi, see  here.)


In the indigenous view psi is just there along with a lot of other phenomena -- it's part of the patterns people observe, and part of the correlation between dreaming mind and everyday life, and part of the correlation between ancestors and nonhuman life (including e.g. rocks which Aboriginals consider to have their own sort of consciousness) and human minds, etc.    


The mercurial nature of psi phenomena, which gives us such a headache as scientists seeking replicable results, is not a problem from the indigenous view -- it's just how the world works.


In fact, conjecturing a bit, I vaguely suspect Yunkaporta would view the modern civilized-society obsession with the small percentage of phenomena in the universe that are reliably repeatable as an indication of our modern civilized mental un-health.   


Consider e.g. the analogue of romantic relationships.  There is all sorts of special-case magic in romantic relationships -- special moments that will never be repeated -- ad hoc exploitations of beautiful situations or unique moods -- and that is fine and wonderful and part of the beauty of it all.   Obsessing on those portions of a romantic relationship that are highly reliably repeatable in the same precise form, without contextual variability -- would seem crass and ridiculous.   (Every time I give her a sufficient number of flowers of the appropriate species and purchase her an evening meal at a restaurant with a sufficiently high rating by a reputable source, she must respond by inviting me for a night of passionate lovemaking -- and if this  fails too often because of some unpredicted variability in aspects of the context in the world or her brain or body or one of our life-processes, then that proves the pattern is inadequate and we must seek a more rigorous and reliable pattern !!) ....  


One could view the obsession with repeatability and reliability (in psi research and elsewhere) from this perspective, as a weird/twisted focus on certain small corners of the broader universe, most of which just doesn't play by that sort of highly simplistic rulebook....


I've suggested before that  basic progress on psi might require modification of our concept of science in the direction of "second person science", where e.g. brain computer interfacing is used to enable one observer to directly perceive another observer's perception of phenomena -- so that we can compare subjective observations directly without needing to project them wholly into non-experiential data.


Quite possibly, another sense in which our current conception of science may need to be obsoleted/ transcended, is that we need to move beyond our simplistic notion of "repeatability"....  Psi is contextually dependent in the same sort of way that indigenous knowledge is contextually dependent (which is related to but maybe stronger than the sense in which quantum knowledge is contextually dependent).   Charlie Tart's wonderful notion of state-specific science is going in this direction -- it's a particular sort of example of context-specific science....


I am reminded of a chat I heard among psi researchers not long ago, which may be paraphrased as:


A::

Can you think of ANY pre-registered, high statistical power, multi-lab psi replication that was successful?


B::

The PEAR consortium in 2000 tried to replicate the original PEAR findings and although the main effect of intention was not significant, they did find a number of interesting effects and anomalous aspects in the data.


C:

I’m aware of those results, but the question was about robust replication.  Finding post hoc "interesting  effects” doesn’t qualify.


A’s question initially seems like a good one; but I just wonder if, somehow or other, to really grapple with psi we need to find a broader notion of success in which finding post hoc "interesting internal effects" DOES qualify...


Yes, one can fool oneself and see interesting post hoc effects in random noise.  However,one can also see genuinely interesting post hoc effects that are not the same as what one was looking for, yet have some meaty surprisingness value to them...


How to quantify this?  Taking a broad-minded Bayesian sort of view, one could ask: In a universe with mercurial psi, versus a universe with none, would this post-hoc effect be more likely to occur?    


Across a host of different experiments with weird post-hoc effects but not accurate replicationof prior results, this sort of question becomes more and more meaningful.   It's not an easy way to look at things, and it's better asked in the context of meaningful concrete models of "universes with mercurial psi", but something in this direction may be better than trying to shove funky / trickstery / mercurial phenomena into a bin of "highly repetitive, replicable phenomena" where they just plain don't fit...


The general notion that psi is "trickstery" is definitely far from new.   However what I’m thinking that may be new is:  How to make a data-analytics methodology that accounts for this aspect...


What if one simply takes the mass of data from a bunch of psi studies and


  1. searches for surprising psi-ish patterns in the data using general pattern-analysis tools

  2. does a comparable search for such patterns in appropriately shuffled versions of the data


To keep things statistically valid, one would want to explore 1) using a variety of pattern-analysis approaches, and then once one feels one has really got something, one tries 2) for validation. Obviously 2) should not be part of one’s main pattern-search loop.


Of course the cosmic trickster could also troll this analysis by -- as soon as one has done this analysis -- starting to tweak experimental results so as to give bad results according to one's particular mathematical definition of surprisingness, but good results according to some other definition, etc.


But yet -- the cosmic trickster is obviously not being infinitely tricky in all instances, sometimes just highly tricky -- and trying to outsmart their tricks is part of the grand eurycosmic dance in which we find ourselves ...


When I shared some of these thoughts with a leading psi researcher, he recalled a time he gave a talk in Australia,, and an aboriginal elder from the audience approached him afterwards, whispering that her people had been using psi for over 50,000 years, but that it was nice to see science starting to catch up.


37 comments:

Mike said...

The convergence is near enough. Bracing myself for the cognitive dissonance as it slowly dawns on them...

Payal Singh said...

Hi Guys! Welcome to Mahipalpur Escorts it is extremely near Delhi International Airport. This is a bustling metropolitan town that has numerous inns alongside staple goods and exquisite bloom shops in South Delhi, on the off chance that you are searching for a carrier Call girls in Mahipalpur, you can take the benefits of it very quickly.

drivenperformancechiropractic said...

Really it was an amazing post and engaged the audience with your blog. keep writing more Blog. I also recommend visiting Chiropractic Care for specialized in treatment care for neuromusculoskeletal injuries

streamfortyseven said...

My bet is that most psi research is made simply impossible by the observer effect. And most psi data I've seen has got much more noise than signal, so if you do pattern recognition, you'll wind up with "patterns" which bear no significance. And data reduction by humans - there's that observer effect again. Of course, you know - I know - that psi does exist, anecdotally, much like homeopathic medicines work - but it's all anecdotal evidence. But doing RCT produces no results, time after time. And if you say they work by placebo effect, that simply names the phenomenon with explaining its mechanism, you "explain it away."

Sonam Sharma said...


Play Your Bedroom Fantasies With Delhi Escorts Girls 24/7
Want to Spend some time with an Erotic Delhi Escorts are here to take care.We have a Beautiful Delhi Call girls Collection of ladies to make you feel good & relaxed and these ladies can offer you the most Exotic Girlfriend & Sensual Massage services. You can book a home & hotels delivery anywhere in Delhi.
Delhi Escorts
Delhi Escorts
Aerocity Escorts

Anonymous said...

Beautiful Blog, Thanks for sharing helpful and infomative content.
Hyderabad escorts Service for Fun Night Fun

Meerut Call Girl Looking so Gorgeous

Jaipur Escorts (Pink City) Tourist Place

Jaipur Call Girls Give You Sexy Service

Jaipur Calls Girls 24/7 Book

Dehradun escorts Russian Call Girls

call girls in Agra (Taj Mahal)

Dehradun Escorts Service with Hot Call Girls

Anonymous said...

Sexy Escorts Service In Hyderabad

Hyderabad Housewife Escorts Service​

Cheap Escorts Service Service In Hyderabad

High Profile Escorts Service Hyderabad

Hyderabad Sex Escorts Service​

Housewife Escorts Service Hyderabad

Sex Escorts Service In Hyderabad

Escorts Service Services In Hyderabad

Female Escorts Service Service In Hyderabad

Hyderabad Escorts Service Whatsapp Number​

Bangalore Escorts Divya Goal said...

Bangalore Escorts
Bangalore Escorts
Bangalore Escorts
Bangalore Escorts
Bangalore Escorts
Bangalore Escorts
Bangalore Escorts

top mba programs in canada said...

Thanks for sharing this information if you want to read about top mba programs in canadathen do please visit our blog.

Anonymous said...

Right before I divorced my wife I was complaining to my father that we had not had sex for quite some time. He told me in all seriousness, "Sometimes you need to buy them a little something special." I looked at him angrily and said, "If what I wanted was a hooker then I would've never gotten married to begin with." I basically called my mother a whore. In hindsight I was being overly nice.

QuickBooks Support said...

I am very thankful for such a wonderful blog. It's very interesting to read and easy to understand. Thanks for sharing. I will visit your blog daily because I know. It may be very beneficial for me. For instant support related to Common QuickBooks Pro Error please contact our team for instant help.

Field Engineer said...

Thank you for sharing.

Field Engineer responsibilities typically include handling maintaining, monitoring, installing and providing support for network hardware, software and communication links.

For more information about: field engineer

corpac said...

Plastic corrugated roofing sheets is among the top companies involved in manufacturing and exporting Plastic Corrugated Roofing Sheets under the brand name CorpacInd. Established in 1998, the company has its state-of-the-art facility located at Kaharani, Bhiwadi, in Rajasthan. It manufactures Corrugated plastic roofing sheets, Polypropylene Corrugated Sheets, etc., under a roof. The skilled professionals, modern technology and advanced production facility support it's objective most extraordinarily. CorpacInd’s plastic corrugated roofing sheets combine incredible resistance to chemicals, fire and impact, ensuring an excellent durable roofing solution from the corrugated plastic roofing material which withstands extreme chemical environments.

satyaET said...

Great information thank you World's Best Turmeric Powder

Special Writings said...

I acknowledge the point that you want to highlight and think it should be important among the audience. Actually our principal purpose should be to give high-quality content to our blog or web visitors.

John Hardy said...

I really like your article. There is an indirect connection here to the relational interpretation of quantum mechanics. Thanks for sharing this article. Now it's time to avail HALFCASTE CREAM SET for more information.

Max Roy said...

Thank you so much for this excellent blog article. Your writing style and the way you have presented your content is awesome. Now it's time to avail Siding Services In Alachua County FL for more information.

Anonymous said...

Verified & Legit Fullz Provider
Fresh & Never used Before
Invalid will be replace

Telegram @killhacks / @leadsupplier
ICQ 752822040 / @killhacks
Email hacksp007 @ DNMX.org

SSN/SIN DOB DL FULLZ (USA|UK|CANADA)
High Credit Scores Fullz (700+)
CC With CVV
Dumps With PIN Track 101 & 202
DL Scan Front & Back
Dead Fullz
Specific Info Fullz Cities|States|Gender|Zip's
Office365 Emails & Logins
SMTP|RDP|SHELS|C-PANEL|WEB-MAILER

All stuff will be genuine & guaranteed
Bulk quantity available
Serious buyers will be welcome

abogado de divorcio sin oposición playa de virginia said...

Embark on a mind-expanding trip via 'Sand Talk,' explore the mysteries of Singularity, and dive into the worlds of Psi. In this enthralling investigation of many topics, discover the secrets that lay beyond the commonplace.Thank you for sharing your knowledge! Keep up the good job! Continue to spread the word. Please take a peek at my website.

Ariel said...

This is very well written and your blog points are great!

Poppy said...

Wow, superb weblog structure! The whole site is great. Im happy I found this

Eaton said...

I will be very happy to discover this kind of post very useful personally.

Anonymous said...

SSN DOB DL ADDRESS FULLZ
SIN DOB ADDRESS FULLZ
NIN DOB ADDRESS FULLZ
High Credit Scores Pros
Original & Real ID/DL Scan front back with Selfie
CC with CVV Fullz
Cloning Card Dumps Track 101 & 202
UBEREATS|DOORDASH|PUA|SBA|UI|Tax Return Filling Fullz
Young Age Fullz
Business EIN Company Fullz

Specific info FULLZ also providing (CITIES|STATES|AGE|DOB|ZIP's)
Tools & Tutorials providing too
SMTP|RDP|C-Panel|SHELLS|Web-Mailer|Brutes|OfficeSMTP

Many Other Stuff Available
Legit stuff & Guaranteed
If anything going wrong I'll replace
No Refund|Only Replacement

Contact Here
Telegram @killhacks | @leadsupplier
ICQ 752822040 | @killhacks
Email hacksp007 @ DNMX . org
Skype @peeterhacks

สล็อต said...

สล็อต เครดิตฟรี 50 ถอนได้ 300 ค่ายเกมที่กำลังเติบโตและก้าวหน้าอย่างมหาศาลในวงการเกมออนไลน์ในยุคปัจจุบัน PG ด้วยความเป็นที่นิยมและความน่าเชื่อถือของเกมที่มีคุณภาพสูง

Pierce Alexander said...

I found so many interesting stuff in this blog. Really its great article. Keep it up

Jayceon Freeman said...

Wow, happy to see this awesome post. Thanks for sharing a great information.

Eliana Christensen said...

Fantastic post! Please keep sharing post like this. Thanks, have a good day.

Miranda McKinney said...

Hi there to every body, this webpage contains amazing and excellent data.

Clementine Donalds said...

Great post! We will be linking to this great post on our website. Keep it up

스포츠 토토사이트 said...

I wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts.

sportstoto.link said...

Big thumbs up for making such wonderful blog page!

pachinkosite.info said...

I have learned lot of things from it regarding blogging. thanks.

ISO Certification Saudi Arabia said...

This article is a revelation. I’ve read about this topic before, but it’s never been this clear. The writer has done an amazing job of making it understandable for everyone. Kudos for the fantastic work!

Visit our link for ISO Certification in Riyadh

카지노사이트 추천 said...

Extremely pleasant and fascinating post. Continue posting. We're waiting Thanks

메이저사이트 said...

I enjoy this kinds of own post. It Like this knowledgeable blog here.

사설 토토사이트 said...

I hope you continue to do this awesome blog work, I support you for your writing

파워볼사이트 추천 said...

Your creative writing abilities inspired me to get my own blog. Thank you